Took me three tries at two different Trader Joe’s, but I finally was able to get the key ingredient: Better n’ Peanut Butter spread. Oh my god. This shake is so delicious.
Thank you, Hungry Girl! Recipe here!
Okay, so I messed up the recipe a bit. Instead of a pudding cup, I used half of a pudding mix. Instead of 3 packets of Splenda I used one Sweet N Low. I’m serious, it is soooo good. You HAVE to try it! Sinless peanut butter, icey goodness!